S Corp | C Corp | SP | GP | LLC | LP | LLP | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Certificate of Incorporation | Certificate of Incorporation | Default – no filing | Default – no filing | Must file under state LLC Act | Must file w/Secretary of State | Must file a certificate w/OK Secretary of State |
| Board of Directors manages business, not S/Hs | Board of Directors manages business, not S/Hs | Only 1 owner who directly manages everything | Partners have = rights to manage the business, unless they agree otherwise | Member-Managed: Mgmt is shared among the owners Mgr.-Managed: day-to-day operations conducted by “mgrs.” | Limited Partners don’t have mgmt rights – mgmt is in hands of General Partners | Partners have = rights to manage the business, unless they agree otherwise |
| Ltd Liability: S/Hs, board members, & officers not personally liable for business debts of business – paid out of corp assets S/Hs – Veil Piercing | Ltd Liability: S/Hs, board members, & officers not personally liable for business debts of business – paid out of corp assets S/Hs – Veil Piercing | Debts paid from the personal assets of the owner. Individuals are always liable for their personal wrongdoing & for Ks they guarantee | Partners personally liable for the debts of the business—arguably more risky than SP bc also liable for acts of other partners & bc are fragile | Liability of owners (“members”) is limited – not liable for debts of the business | Ltd. Partners are exempt fr liability for debts of firm General Partners are not exempt from liability for debts of firm Both have ltd. liability for tortious acts of other partners | (1) Full Shield States: offer protection fr liability for debts of the business & acts of others (2) Partial Shield States: ltd. liability which shields partners fr vicarious liability for the acts of others, but not debts of business |
| Flow-thru Taxation | Double Taxation | Net income fr business is TI to the SP | Flow-Through | Flow-Through, UNLESS an election is made to be treated as a corporation | Flow-Through | Flow-Through |
| Sale of Shares | Sale of Shares | Easy – only 1 person | Can exit whenever (subject to K), but cashing out can be difficult if nobody interested in buying Usually contractual buyout arrangements w/fellow partners | Doesn’t have to cause a dissolution of the LLC | More confined Under many statutes, LPs are entitled to a return of their capital after some period after giving notice of withdrawal, unless p’ship agreement specifies otherwise | Same as GP – can exit at any time, but may be difficult cashing out – usually contractual buying arrangements w/fellow partners |
| S/H in S Corp only pays SE taxes on the portion of the income that’s attributable to services & any amt in excess of that is considered a return on your investment & is not subject to SE tax | Taking out salary in C Corps is subject to self-employment taxes, so would want to pay out dividends instead | A partner’s distributive share of income fr. a p’ship constitutes earnings fr self-employment | A partner’s distributive share of income fr. a p’ship constitutes earnings fr self-employment Want to fit into limited p’ship exception | GR: Not going to be treated like a limited partner & will have to pay SE taxes Subj. to SE taxes on the income IF 1 of 3 things: (1) have personal liability for the debts of LLC (2) have authority to K OBO LLC, or (3) participate in the bus of the LLC >500 hrs during taxable yrs | LPs are generally not subj. to SE taxes GP under state law is exposed to SE taxes | |
| Gains realized on sale of the assets are taxed to the owners in proportion to their interests in the business, & after those taxes are pd the owners pocket the net proceeds | Worst option b/c of dbl tax, but is mitigated | Gains realized on sale of the assets are taxed to the owners in proportion to their interests in the business, & after those taxes are pd the owners pocket the net proceeds | Gains realized on sale of the assets are taxed to the owners in proportion to their interests in the business, & after those taxes are pd the owners pocket the net proceeds | Gains realized on sale of the assets are taxed to the owners in proportion to their interests in the business, & after those taxes are pd the owners pocket the net proceeds | Gains realized on sale of the assets are taxed to the owners in proportion to their interests in the business, & after those taxes are pd the owners pocket the net proceeds | Gains realized on sale of the assets are taxed to the owners in proportion to their interests in the business, & after those taxes are pd the owners pocket the net proceeds |
| DO increase basis | Do not increase basis (taxable gain can be huge then) | DO increase basis | DO increase basis | DO increase basis | DO increase basis | DO increase basis |
| Very little flexibility—can only have 1 class of stock! Only voting & non-voting common stock | Can offer diff types of common & preferred stock | Can customize & define diff interests in the operating agreement | Offer most flexibility: member-managed vs. mgr.-managed Can customize & define diff interests in the operating agreement | Offer most flexibility – Ltd Partners vs. General Partners Can customize & define diff interests in the operating agreement | Can customize & define diff interests in the operating agreement | |
| Not a problem | Problem!! C Corp bails out its earnings by distributing them to its S/Hs as dividends, which the corp pays a tax on & is taxed again at S/H level. BUT – could restructure as salary & be deductible to C Corp Toiler & Prof. Service Orgs | Not a problem | Not a problem | Not a problem | Not a problem | Not a problem |
| Ltd. Options – if converts to p’ship or LLC, a gain on the liquidation of the corp will be triggered at corp & S/H levels Can convert into S Corp b/c doesn’t auto trigger such gain | ||||||
| C Corps that aren’t Pers. Service Corps have a tiered graduated rate Businesses who are not pers. Service orgs should consider the lower C Corp rates to help service debt, inventories, etc. | ||||||
| Provide best control opportunities bc in a corp you can be the sole member of the bd. of directors & the majority S/H who runs the corp | Provide best control opportunities bc in a corp you can be the sole member of the bd. of directors & the majority S/H who runs the corp | Not an issue | Control rights must be spelled out in the operating agreement | Control rights must be spelled out in the operating agreement | Can put most of the control in the General Partner | |
| In order to offset passive income w/passive losses, must pass material participation standard ea. individual owner | May offset its active business income w/passive losses | In order to offset passive income w/passive losses, must pass material participation standard ea. individual owner | In order to offset passive income w/passive losses, must pass material participation standard ea. individual owner | In order to offset passive income w/passive losses, must pass material participation standard ea. individual owner | In order to offset passive income w/passive losses, must pass material participation standard ea. individual owner | In order to offset passive income w/passive losses, must pass... |