Law Outlines Tort Law Outlines
All of the notes you will ever need for a Tort Law final examination. Contains notes on cases, Restatements, statutes, the Constitution, and more....
The following is a more accessible plain text extract of the PDF sample above, taken from our Tort Law Outlines. Due to the challenges of extracting text from PDFs, it will have odd formatting:
PRODUCTS LIABILITY
Elements: 1) Duty
2) Breach
3) Causation
4) Damages
|
---|
Duty
Products Liability is a matter of Strict Liability
Escola v. Coca Cola Bottling Co of Fresno (Manufacturing defect)
Facts:
Escola (P) was a waitress who was filling a restaurant refrigerator with Coke bottles that had been delivered to the restaurant at least thirty-six hours earlier. As she placed the fourth bottle in the refrigerator, it exploded in her hand, causing severe injuries. Escola (P) claimed that Coca Cola (D) was negligent in selling a bottle that, because of excessive pressure or because of some other defect in the bottle, was dangerous and likely to explode.
Holding:
A manufacturer is strictly liable when a product it puts on the market, knowing it will be used without inspection, had a defect that causes injury to human beings
Reasoning:
Loss Minimization
Manufacturer rather than the customer is in the best and mostknowledgeable position to minimize the losses that arise out ofthegeneral use of itsproduct
LossSpreading
Ability of thedefendant producer to spread thedamages among many consumers, thus cushioning the overwhelming misfortune of the injured person or his family
Elimination ofproof complication
StrictLiability rule switches the residual risk ofunavoidable accidents from theplaintiff to thedefendant
innegligence, plaintiff had toprove breach - plaintiff often has noidea ofwhathappened tothe product before it reached her
Res IpsaLoquiturdoesn’t help all the way
creates a presumption ofbreach, but presumptions can be disproven = the jurydoesn’t have tobelieve them
Don’t allow some defendants toescape liability when they happen to have someproof = the rest is strict liability
Here defendants are in a position to figure out alternatives (plaintiffcan’t do that when establishing breach), they are the only ones that know what other precautions they can take and what their process is like
Foodstuffs Analogy
there used to be a distinction between foodstuffs that were sold insealed containers and those that were not
For goods sold insealed containers, the law exempted the retailer fromliability but allowed direct suit against the manufacturer, onnegligence theory
Criminal strict liability statutes = for selling adulterated food
If this kind of liability for foodstuffs, then civil strictliability for manufacturers forfoodstuffs and similar products
Corrective Justice
Once plaintiff establishes the casual connection to the defendant’s act, then prima facie, the loss should be placed upon the party who created that condition, not the party who suffered from it
With products liability, thedefendant is never inpossession ofthedangerousproduct when it causes injury so that the older privity limitation becomes asensible way forliability to track possession, save in those fewcases in which a party out of possession is in a better position to avoid the loss
Times are Changing
In today’s world of mass production, consumers no longer can investigate or inspect for themselves the soundness of a product, but must rely on the manufacturer. The manufacturing process is often inaccessible to the public. The manufacturer uses advertising, trademarks, and warranty programs to create a justifiable faith in the quality of its products.
An injured person is not ordinarily in a position to overcome this evidence or affirmatively prove the existence of negligence.
There is no mutuality of risk here – one person is taking the risk
McPherson v Buick Motor Co - Cardozo(Manufacturing Defect)
At the time, consumers could sue manufactures of productswhen thoseproducts were inherently dangerous
In this case, the wooden wheel of a cartshattered as soon as the driver left the lot
He said, carts too are inherently dangerous ifnegligently made
Can you think of a product that is not inherently dangerous ifnegligently made?
Virtually allproducts are inherently dangerous if negligently made
Then all products impose a duty to theirconsumers
Greenman v. Yuba Power Products Inc. (Design Defect)
Plaintiff’s wife gave him a Shopsmith combination power tool manufactured but he defendant, that could be used as a saw, a drill and a wood lathe. After reading the brochure, and in the court of working the lathe, a piece of wood suddenly flew out and hit the plaintiff, injuring him. There was substantial evidence that the plaintiff’s injures were caused by defective construction.
Plaintiff recovered damages from the manufacturer for negligence and breach of both express and implied warranties.
Defendant was trying to say that shouldn’t be the case because didn’t give timely notice of injures
Court said no - manufacturer is strictly liable in tort when an article he places on the market, knowing it to be used without inspection for defects, proves to have defect that causes injury to a human being
Manufacturer is not in a place to determine scope of his own liabilities, there is strict liability - not a matter of contract or relationship between manufacturer and consumer.
To establish liability, it was sufficient that the plaintiff proved that he was injured while using the tool in a way that it was intended to be used as a result of a defect in design and manufacture of which plaintiff was not aware that made the tool unsafe for its intended use
Engberg v. Ford Motor Co
plaintiff’s husband was killed when he drove his station wagon, purchased two weeks earlier from defendant, off the highway into a ditch. No other cars involved, and parties...
Buy the full version of these notes or essay plans and more in our Tort Law Outlines.
All of the notes you will ever need for a Tort Law final examination. Contains notes on cases, Restatements, statutes, the Constitution, and more....
Ask questions 🙋 Get answers 📔 It's simple 👁️👄👁️
Our AI is educated by the highest scoring students across all subjects and schools. Join hundreds of your peers today.
Get Started